|
Credit
Tenant Lease ("CTL") transactions focus more on the
credit of the tenant and the lease structure than on the type,
quality, and location of the real estate. The CTL lease structure
typically requires the tenant to pay directly any expenses for
which they are responsible. If the lease is structured like a
real estate deal with the tenant reimbursing the landlord, a
funded reserve account is required.
PRIVATE
PLACEMENTS
Private placements are fixed income securities that are not registered
with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). As such, they
are not publicly issued and are not required to be rated by a
rating agency. The securities do require a rating by the NAIC
if they are sold to a life insurance company. A rating of NAIC
1 (AAA through A-) or NAIC 2 (BBB+ through BBB-) are acceptable
credits to most private placement purchasers. A rating of NAIC
3 (implied non-investment grade) may be placed depending upon
the firm's industry rating and the business outlook.
PRICING
The pricing of loans is based on the credit of the tenant and
the investment community's perception of the tenant's credit
and business. Investors often perceive a difference in the quality
of two tenants with the same credit rating. Thus, two deals with
different tenants that have the same rating may be priced differently.
LOAN
TO VALUE
The maximum loan to value in CTL transactions is 100%.
LOAN
TO DARK
Loan to dark is designed to factor in any rent premiums a credit
tenant is willing to pay for a particular location. The appraiser
determines the appropriate market rental rate for the space and
uses this rental rate to determine the go-dark value. This value
determination rarely limits the loan amount in a private placement
structure, but is often a limiting factor in a securitized CTL
transaction.
DEBT
SERVICE COVERAGE RATIO (DSCR)
The minimum DSCR on a private placement CTL ranges from 1.00x
to 1.05x
RENT
INCREASES
Fixed rent increases can be factored into structuring a CTL and
have the impact of supporting greater loan proceeds. The amortization
schedule usually changes with each rent increase. Rent increases
tied to changes in the CPI cannot be considered unless there
is a minimum increase, which can be underwritten.
RESIDUAL
VALUE INSURANCE
Residual value insurance, which typically costs 4-5% of the residual
value insured amount, is an option when a borrower desires a
longer amortization schedule and/or more loan dollars. Residual
value insurance ranges from 25-45% of the initial loan amount
with some as high as 50%+ for offices. The amount depends on
the type of real estate, the lease structure, term, and the location.
"GAP" INSURANCE
Gap insurance is required any time the tenant has a termination
right in the event of a condemnation or casualty. For private
placement transactions only condemnation insurance is required
if the tenant has a termination right for condemnation or casualty
and the one-time cost is approximately 40 basis points of the
loan amount. With a securitized CTL, both condemnation and casualty
gap insurance is required and the total cost is nearly three
time greater than for private placement CTLs. The cost of the
gap insurance is a one-time cost paid at closing.
SEPARATE
PARCEL
The collateral for a CTL transaction must have a separate tax
parcel to qualify for CTL treatment. The property may be encumbered
by a reciprocal easement agreement; however, if the maintenance
expense reimbursements are not paid directly by the tenant, a
reserve will be established.
ASSIGNABILITY
The tenant may have the right to assign its lease as long as
it remains responsible for the obligations under the lease.
SELF
INSURANCE
Tenants often have self-insurance language in their leases. This
can be acceptable if, in addition to a $100 million minimum net
worth requirement, they have an investment-grade credit rating
requirement. Sometimes with self-insurance language, the tenant
does not carry all risk coverage. In that case, the landlord
needs to obtain difference in coverage (DIC) coverage. This expense
amount is a deduction in determining NOI for DSCR calculation.
UNDERWRITTEN
EXPENSES
With the exception of a marginal Annual Trustee/Servicer fee,
no deductions are taken from the lease payments to arrive at
cash flow available for debt service.
In
the event the landlord has obligations under the lease, a management
fee of .5 to 1.0% (depending on the size of the loan) is deducted
along with a reserve to cover landlord obligations. If rent abates
following a casualty and the tenant is not obligated to carry
rent loss insurance, the landlord is required to purchase 12
month's rent loss coverage and the premium is deducted in arriving
at net cash flow. The minimum DSCR for leases with landlord obligations
is 1.05x. |